2021年Vultr日本机房再测评:日本NTT,三网速度不错,移动丢包高

最近看见好几次有人夸电信扩容后Vultr日本机房国内表现非常不错,于是VPS GO就自费买了一台,跑了下测试脚本,从结果来看,电信扩容后Vultr日本机房确实变快了不少,但是国内丢包依然比较高,尤其是中国移动,丢包高到根本用不了。

一、机房介绍

Vultr新用户优惠(新用户注册送50美元):https://www.vultr.com/promo/try50/

Vultr日本机房的价格是月付5美元起,位于日本东京,日本NTT线路,1核1G,25GB SSD存储,每个月1000GB流量。

Vultr日本节点测试信息:

  • 测试IP:108.61.201.151
  • 测速文件:100MB

二、整体测评

先看下bench的整体测评,Vultr日本VPS的IO是真的厉害,高达1.6GB/s,带宽测试上传速度6Gbps,下载速度3Gbps,国内和国际的速度也不错:

Vultr日本机房测评

三、速度测试

同样的,分别在白天和晚高峰对Vultr日本机房进行了国内三网速度测试,速度表现确实不错,电信、移动和联通的速度都可以。

白天速度测试:

Vultr日本机房测评

晚高峰速度测试:

Vultr日本机房测评

再补测了下移动:

Vultr日本机房测评

四、延迟测试

Vultr日本机房的延迟甚至比美国机房还要高,多线平均250ms:

Vultr日本机房测评

五、丢包测试

丢包很高,尤其是移动,将近90的丢包率,根本用不起来:

Vultr日本机房测评

六、路由测试

Vultr日本机房应该是日本NTT线路,但是由于IP归属地的问题,路由测试结果非常奇怪,大家就随便看看吧。

电信去程路由:

Vultr日本机房路由测试

联通去程路由:

Vultr日本机房路由测试

移动去程路由:

Vultr日本机房路由测试

广州电信回程路由:

traceroute to 113.108.209.1 (113.108.209.1), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  62.115.41.150  0.50 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 6  62.115.41.150  0.90 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 7  62.115.123.140  106.83 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 8  202.97.81.85  108.00 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
 9  202.97.81.85  107.37 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
10  202.97.94.117  165.83 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
11  202.97.94.149  163.91 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
12  113.108.208.218  168.01 ms  AS58466  China, Guangdong, Guangzhou, ChinaTelecom
13  *
14  113.108.209.1  160.81 ms  AS58466  China, Guangdong, Guangzhou, ChinaTelecom

上海电信回程路由:

traceroute to 180.153.28.5 (180.153.28.5), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  62.115.41.150  0.48 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 6  62.115.123.140  106.41 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 7  *
 8  202.97.83.25  110.91 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
 9  61.152.25.133  153.18 ms  AS4812  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom
10  101.95.207.6  187.93 ms  AS4812  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom
11  101.95.225.158  169.60 ms  AS4811  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom
12  101.95.88.93  244.07 ms  AS4812  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom
13  *
14  101.95.225.206  244.45 ms  AS4811  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom
15  180.153.28.5  168.60 ms  AS4812  China, Shanghai, ChinaTelecom

北京电信回程路由:

traceroute to 180.149.128.9 (180.149.128.9), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  *
 6  62.115.123.140  106.42 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 7  218.30.54.181  110.11 ms  AS4134  United States, California, Los Angeles, ChinaTelecom
 8  202.97.81.177  107.49 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
 9  202.97.81.177  108.18 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
10  202.97.28.121  157.88 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
11  202.97.12.61  150.30 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
12  180.149.159.6  156.90 ms  AS23724  China, Beijing, ChinaTelecom
13  180.149.128.9  166.66 ms  AS23724  China, Beijing, ChinaTelecom

北京联通回程路由:

traceroute to 123.125.99.1 (123.125.99.1), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  *
 6  129.250.3.23  2.16 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 7  129.250.3.23  3.19 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 8  129.250.7.33  8.81 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 9  219.158.32.33  104.70 ms  AS4837  China, ChinaUnicom
10  219.158.16.77  182.71 ms  AS4837  China, ChinaUnicom
11  219.158.16.77  176.98 ms  AS4837  China, ChinaUnicom
12  202.96.12.182  118.56 ms  AS4808  China, Beijing, ChinaUnicom
13  61.148.157.170  124.44 ms  AS4808  China, Beijing, ChinaUnicom
14  124.65.194.122  170.61 ms  AS4808  China, Beijing, ChinaUnicom
15  61.135.113.158  157.62 ms  AS4808  China, Beijing, ChinaUnicom
16  *
17  *
18  *
19  123.125.99.1  113.27 ms  AS4808  China, Beijing, ChinaUnicom

上海联通回程路由:

traceroute to 58.247.8.158 (58.247.8.158), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  *
 6  120.88.54.97  1.24 ms  AS2914  Japan, Tokyo, ntt.com
 7  129.250.7.79  11.54 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 8  129.250.7.81  24.06 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 9  129.250.66.86  85.12 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
10  219.158.113.118  111.56 ms  AS4837  China, ChinaUnicom
11  219.158.113.109  149.43 ms  AS4837  China, ChinaUnicom
12  *
13  58.247.221.178  148.53 ms  AS17621  China, Shanghai, ChinaUnicom
14  58.247.221.178  100.03 ms  AS17621  China, Shanghai, ChinaUnicom
15  139.226.225.22  149.74 ms  AS17621  China, Shanghai, ChinaUnicom
16  58.247.8.153  110.22 ms  AS17621  China, Shanghai, ChinaUnicom

广州移动回程路由:

traceroute to 113.108.209.1 (113.108.209.1), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  62.115.41.150  0.50 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 6  62.115.41.150  0.90 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 7  62.115.123.140  106.83 ms  AS1299  Sweden, Stockholm County, Stockholm, telia.com
 8  202.97.81.85  108.00 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
 9  202.97.81.85  107.37 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
10  202.97.94.117  165.83 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
11  202.97.94.149  163.91 ms  AS4134  China, ChinaTelecom
12  113.108.208.218  168.01 ms  AS58466  China, Guangdong, Guangzhou, ChinaTelecom
13  *
14  113.108.209.1  160.81 ms  AS58466  China, Guangdong, Guangzhou, ChinaTelecom

北京移动回程路由:

traceroute to 211.136.25.153 (211.136.25.153), 30 hops max, 32 byte packets
 1  *
 2  *
 3  *
 4  *
 5  120.88.54.97  1.22 ms  AS2914  Japan, Tokyo, ntt.com
 6  120.88.54.97  1.16 ms  AS2914  Japan, Tokyo, ntt.com
 7  129.250.3.23  0.85 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 8  129.250.6.98  46.85 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
 9  129.250.6.98  47.89 ms  AS2914  United States, ntt.com
10  *
11  *
12  *
13  *
14  *
15  *
16  *
17  *
18  *
19  *
20  *
21  *
22  *
23  *
24  *
25  *
26  *
27  *
28  *
29  *
30  *

七、测评总结

跟2020年的测评相比(《Vultr日本东京机房测评:速度、延迟、丢包率和路由测试》),电信扩容后Vultr日本机房的速度确实变好了,但是丢包依然是惨不忍睹,延迟也非常高,总结一句话,日本NTT还是不能使用。

如果你需要日本VPS,那么可以考虑下价格还算平民的日本软银线路,这次扩容后延迟低、速度快,之前VPS GO也分享过对比:《搬瓦工日本和Vultr日本机房对比,哪个好,怎么选?》,这是电信扩容后的测评,国内表现非常好:《电信扩容后搬瓦工日本大阪软银机房评测:丢包减少、延迟稳定、速度变快(甚至跑满带宽)


【AD】DMIT,美国CMIN2 VPS,8折优惠,折后$23.10/季(1核2G/20G SSD /[email protected]流量),三网回程CMIN2

【AD】美国洛杉矶CN2 VPS/香港CN2 VPS/日本CN2 VPS推荐,延迟低、稳定性高、免费备份_搬瓦工vps